View this PageEdit this PageUploads to this PageHistory of this PageHomeRecent ChangesSearchHelp Guide

gi


Paper number: ???

Title: The importance of social interaction

Submission type: Survey/Tutorial
/Research paper
Retrospective
Survey/Tutorial
Project overview
Other/


[All submission types]
Relevance to magazine: 4
/5 = Burning issue of the day; 4 = Timely and relevant;
3 = Worth reporting;
2 = Yawn; 1 = Much ado about nothing/


[All submission types]
Presentation and clarity: 4
/5 = Lucid and eloquent; 4 = Easily understandable;
3 = Could be improved;
2 = Hard to understand; 1 = Dense and impenetrable/


[All submission types]
Reviewer expertise: 2
/5 = I'm an authority on this topic; 4 = My work overlaps this topic;
3 = I'm know this stuff well, but don't work on it;
2 = I'm somewhat familiar with this stuff; 1 = This is new to me/


[Research papers only]
Depth of contribution: ???
/5 = Deep and Impressive; 4 = Good, but could be improved;
3 = Useful contribution, but not earthshaking;
2 = Ho Hum; 1 = Seriously flawed/


[Retrospectives only]
Historical accuracy and perspective: ???
/5 = Insightful and eye-opening; 4 = Accurate and useful;
3 = Useful, but lacks some balance or detail;
2 = Bland and boring; 1 = Serious distortions and/or omissions/


[Survey/Tutorials only]
Completeness and Balance: 4
/5 = Comprehensive and thorough; 4 = Covers almost everything relevant;
3 = Useful, but some notable omissions;
2 = Patchy and incomplete; 1 = Serious distortions and/or omissions/


[Project overviews only]
Integration: ???
/5 = Fits together like a perfect puzzle; 4 = A few missing pieces;
3 = Big gaps/omissions;
2 = A disjointed mess; 1 = Poorly-disguised research paper/


[All submission types]
Overall recommendation: 2.5
/5 = Award quality; 4 = Accept with minimal revision;
3 = Accept with major revision but no re-reviewing;
2 = Accept with major revision and re-reviewing; 1 = Reject/


Detailed comments for the authors:

/
Replace this comment by as much space as you need: 
/






/Error: this should not happenError: this should not happenError: this should not happenError: this should not happenError: this should not happenError: this should not happenError: this should not happenError: this should not happenError: this should not happenError: this should not happenError: this should not happenError: this should not happenError: this should not happenError: this should not happenError: this should not happenError: this should not happenError: this should not happenError: this should not happenError: this should not happenError: this should not happenError: this should not happenError: this should not happenError: this should not happenError: this should not happenError: this should not happenError: this should not happenError: this should not happen
Information below this line will NOT be seen by authors
Error: this should not happenError: this should not happenError: this should not happenError: this should not happenError: this should not happenError: this should not happenError: this should not happenError: this should not happenError: this should not happenError: this should not happenError: this should not happenError: this should not happenError: this should not happenError: this should not happenError: this should not happenError: this should not happenError: this should not happenError: this should not happenError: this should not happenError: this should not happenError: this should not happenError: this should not happenError: this should not happenError: this should not happenError: this should not happenError: this should not happenError: this should not happen/

Comments for EIC and AEICs only:

/
Replace this comment by as much space as you need: 
/


Reviewer: ???